Friday, September 9, 2011

University Sues Makers of Heart-Healthy Cookies

In a complaint filed September 7 in the Western District of Wisconsin, Brandeis University joins its exclusive licensee (GFA Brands) in suing a number of cookie companies, including Keebler, Famous Amos, Nestlé's and Pillsbury for infringing its patents directed towards methods of "Increasing the HDL Level in the HDL/LDL Ratio in Human Serum by Balancing Saturated and Polyunsaturated Dietary Fatty Acids." As an example, one of the asserted claims is claim 7 of US patent 5,843,497, which recites:

7. A prepared food product, comprising a cholesterol-free fat composition suitable for human or animal ingestion for increasing the HDL concentration and the HDL/LDL concentration ratio in the blood serum, comprising one part by weight polyunsaturated fat and at least one part by weight cholesterol-free saturated fat, where said fat composition comprises linoleic acid and at least one saturated fatty acid selected from the group including lauric acid, myristic acid, and palmitic acid, said linoleic acid constituting between 15% by weight and 40% by weight of the fat in said fat composition and said saturated fatty acid constituting between 20% and 40% by weight of the fat in said fat composition.

Thanks to Docket Report (a service of Docket Navigator) for making me aware of the complaint, which is available here.

One might question the University's decision to patent and exclusively license this discovery, and then proceed to join in a lawsuit against cookie manufacturers apparently employing the fruits of university research in an attempt to make healthier cookies. In an article I published a few years ago with Josh Sarnoff entitled Recent Developments Affecting the Enforcement, Procurement and Licensing of Research Tool Patents (available here), we discussed the policy behind the Bayh-Dole Act, which was primarily intended to increase access to, and the dissemination of, federally-funded University research.

Prior to buy Bayh-Dole, there was a sense that much of the fruits of University research was essentially left sitting on the shelf, due to insufficient incentives for the investment necessary to translate basic University research into useful commercial products. In order to increase the social benefit to be derived from federally funded University research, Bayh-Dole facilitated the ability of universities to patent and license discoveries coming out of such research. But, at least to my understanding, the primary policy justification was not to simply create profit centers for Universities, but rather to permit universities to license patented technologies to companies in the private sector who might only be willing to invest in the commercialization of these technologies if there was some patent protection in place. A good example would be a potentially useful pharmaceutical compound - without a patent in place, few companies would be willing to make the substantial investment the would be required to develop and bring to market a drug based on the compound.

In recent years, there has been much criticism of the manner in which some University technology transfer offices operate, and allegations that university patenting and licensing practices at times impede rather than promote dissemination of the fruits of federally funded University research. For example, in congressional hearings held to address the alleged problem of "gene patents," much of the testimony seemed to suggest that it was University patenting and licensing processes that were more problematic than gene patents per se. In an article I published on human gene patent litigation a few years ago (available here) I found that every gene patent litigation involving genetic diagnostic testing (which is the most controversial use of gene patents) involved gene patents arising out of University research.

In 2007, the trustees of the Association of University Technology Managers (AUTM) published a white paper entitled In the Public Interest: Nine Points to Consider and Licensing University Technology. Point 2 states in part that:

When significant investment of time and resources in a technology are needed in order to achieve its broad implementation, an exclusive license often is necessary and appropriate. However, it is important that technology transfer offices be aware of the potential impact that the exclusive license might have on further research, unanticipated uses, future commercialization efforts and markets. Universities need to be mindful of the impact of granting overly broad exclusive rights and should strive to grant just those rights necessary to encourage development of the technology.
In other words, University technology transfer offices are encouraged to only grant exclusive licenses in technology when a "significant investment of time and resources in a technology are needed in order to achieve its broad implementation." To the extent the patents are licensed exclusively, the University "should strive to grant just those rights necessary to encourage development of the technology."

In this case, the patented technology does not seem to be the type that required a significant investment of time or resources in order to be implemented, as evidenced by the large number of nonlicensed cookie manufacturers who are allegedly employing the suggested "balance of saturated and polyunsaturated dietary fatty acids" in their cookies, presumably in an effort to provide safer products for consumers.

One might question whether the decision of Brandeis University to exclusively license a patent covering these healthy products was the proper decision, or even whether this might be the sort of technology that would be better left unpatented, particularly if one views the University's primary mission as generating and disseminating useful discoveries such as this.

41 comments:

patent litigation said...

While it would, of course, be wonderful if universities and others placed more emphasis on the ethical implications of their decisions, I'm not sure that you can really blame Brandeis. After all, universities participating in the patent system become subject to the same pressures and incentives of other patentees; and the overriding incentive is for patent holders to monetize their IP. I think this situation with Brandeis is a predictable result of the way the patent system is structured; and it also provides an example as to why a vehement anti-IP faction currently thrives.

Tubal Ligation Reversal surgery said...

Wonderful post. I am searching awesome news and idea. What I have found from your site, it is actually highly content. You have spent long time for this post. It's a very useful and interesting site. Thanks!

Anonymous said...

Academic researchers have enjoyed the so-called “research exemption”, and often ignore the IP rights of others (the recent Supreme Court ruling on “Stanford University v. Roche” is a good example). On the other hand, academic institutions have actively and increasingly involved themselves in patent litigations to assert their patent rights (as in this Brandeis case).

The whole thing looks like a double standard to me. You just can't have your cake and eat it, too.

Great Penny Stock Investments said...

Patent Litigation is a rip off just look at the high cost of drugs. Theirs no ethical conduct here.

Penny Stock Recommendations said...

I know a small business owner that has a small business growing broccoli sprouts oat sprouts other types of sprouts. Their was a case pending by some university that was claiming that they had exclusive rights to patent sprouts. The case failed but it goes to show you just how far out of hand this patent and trademark ligation has become.

internet marketing belgium said...

this is really dam good that they are just providing these things food strengths

Leather Jackets said...

It was really a great blog.
Fight Club veste rouge

Mickey Mcginnes said...

creativemachine also often has good discussions but it s not a blog. Just some very sharp sewing enthusiasts from a wide range of.
Avengers Infinity War Robert Downey Jr Jacket

davidmillar said...

A wonderful post which expresses a beautiful sentiment. Unfortunately the. Thank you for sharing your wonderfully moving thoughts with us. At the very least. Solo A Star Wars Story Han Solo Jacket

Ali Gibson said...

green farm 3 mod apk bully anniversary edition mod apk mx player pro apk

Pankaj Singh said...

Thanks for this informative blog, visit Ogen Infosystem for Website Designing Services.
Website Designing Company in Delhi

Unknown said...

Your blog was really impressive. Visit Spin Gurus for learning Music Production Courses and Dj’s.
Audio Engineering Courses

Unknown said...

Y & H Cargo india is the best Shipping and Freight Forwarders service provider in Delhi. Visit
Freight Forwarders in India

Mutual Fundwala said...

Get Mutul Fund Advisors by Mutual Fundwala and know about the investment scheme in mutual fund.
Mutual Fund Advisor

Pradeep Appslure said...

Mobile app development company in toronto

servo stabilizer said...


That was such an awesome content to read and going through it.Thanks for such a good information.our product related for servo voltage stabilizer and transformer.


Servo Stabilizer Manufacturer in india

What is Servo Voltage Stabilizer?

Distribution Transformers Manufacturer in india

What is Step Down Transformer?

Poojarao said...

Rice Bags Manufacturers
Pouch Manufacturers
wall putty bag manufacturers

Poojarao said...

we have provide the best ppc service.
ppc company in gurgaon
website designing company in Gurgaon
PPC company in Noida
PPC Company in Delhi

Poojarao said...

we have provide the best fridge repair service.
fridge repair in faridabad
Videocon Fridge Repair in Faridabad
Whirlpool Fridge Repair in Faridabad
Washing Machine Repair in Noida
godrej washing machine repair in noida
whirlpool Washing Machine Repair in Noida
IFB Machine Repair in Noida
LG Washing Machine Repair in Noida

Poojarao said...

Bali Honeymoon Packages From Delhi
Bali Honeymoon Packages From Chennai
Hong Kong Packages From Delhi
Europe Packages from Delhi
Bali Honeymoon Packages From Bangalore
Bali Honeymoon Packages From Mumbai
Maldives Honeymoon Packages From Bangalore
travel company in Delhi

Just Info said...

Nice blog, thanks for sharing with us. Visit Kala Kutir for Logo Painting, Painting Services and more vehicle branding sevices.
Painting Services in Delhi

carolina classic said...


Nice Blog, keep it up for more updates about this type of blog.Carolina Classics is the manufacturer of best F-100 Classic Ford Truck Parts| Buy Ford F100 truck parts online at Carolina Classics.
Classic Ford Truck Parts
F-100 Ford Truck Parts

Djcareerindia said...

Amazing, thank you so much for sharing such an informative blog. Join the Music Production Courses at Dj Career India in Delhi. Get the best Dj Training School in Delhi, India.
Top DJ Training Schools in Delhi

CHEYEK said...

Very informative post I really like it. Happy to hear about it more.USA Leather Jackek

alaa omran said...

https://companymoversinjeddah.wordpress.com/
شركة نقل عفش بجازان
https://moversriyadhcom.wordpress.com/
https://moversmedina.wordpress.com/
https://moversfurniture2018.wordpress.com/

alaa omran said...

شركة نقل عفش بالقصيم
شركة نقل عفش بتبوك
شركة نقل عفش بابها
شركة نقل عفش بنجران
شركة نقل عفش بحائل


alaa omran said...

شركة نقل اثاث بحفر الباطن
شركة نقل اثاث برابغ
شركة نقل عفش بشرورة
شركة نقل اثاث بعسفان
شركة نقل اثاث بتبوك
شركة نقل اثاث بالخبر

phautecouture said...

Panache Haute Couture, a leading Indian Designer House for Indian Dresses. You can Buy Designer indian wedding dresses lehenga dresses, anarkali suits, indo western bridal gowns,
lehenga choli online, Designer Sarees Online at Online.

lehenga choli


lehenga online

bestieltscoachingindwarka said...

I feel happy about and learning more about this topic. keep sharing your information regularly for my future reference. This content creates new hope and inspiration within me. Thanks for sharing an article like this. the information which you have provided is better than another blog.
IELTS Coaching in Delhi

Pardeep Mengi said...

Usually I never comment on blogs but your article is so convincing that I never stop myself to say something about it. You’re doing a great job Man,Keep it up.
overseas education consultants in delhi
ielts coaching in gurgaon

shipfromca said...

Buy Medicines Online from Ship From CA. No prescription is required for Buy Hydrocodone, Oxycodone, Percocet, Vicodin and Oxycontin Online Overnight from us.
shipfromca

shipfromca said...

Buy hydrocodone online at first-class prices. Hydrocodone or Dihydrocodeinone is used for the treatment of moderate to severe level ache. Hydrocodone dosage is used to treat those people, who need medicine around-the-clock and for folks that do not get pain comfort from other medicinal drugs.

shipfromca said...

At ShipFromCA, you can Buy oxycodone online. Oxycodone is a reasonably effective opioid ache remedy. It is generally usually taken for the remedy of mild to extreme pain. Oxycodone improves the fine of the existence of someone with many varieties of ache. The doctor prescribes oxycodone dose from 10 mg to 80 mg relying on the intensity of ache and patients’ scientific history.

shipfromca said...

Vicodin is an aggregate of narcotic hydrocodone and non-narcotic ache reliever acetaminophen. This drug is helpful for relieving mild to moderately severe acne. It is a prescribed narcotic drug. Vicodin is likewise used as a cough suppressant.If overused, this drug may be addictive. Buy vicodin online
at a low price and rapid transport from Shipfromca.Com

shipfromca said...

Norco is an aggregate of acetaminophen and hydrocodone. Hydrocodone is an opioid pain medicine while Acetaminophen is a less potent pain reliever which will increase the effectiveness of hydrocodone. This drug is prescribed for slight to moderately extreme pain. The dosage of this majorly relies upon the age factor. Buy norco online from ShipFromCA at Low Prices.

shipfromca said...

Buy percocet online. Percocet is a mixture of acetaminophen & oxycodone. This is an opioid/non-opioid pain reliever appropriate for both slight as nicely as extreme pain and also situations associated with pain. Buy Percocet online safely without annoying about the prescription, right here at Ship From CA.

shipfromca said...

ShipFromCA allows you to reserve oc 5 – 80 mg online without RX to cast off your ache. Opioid analgesic is the brand name for oxycontin containing the active factor oxycodone. The same is also observed in Percocet and Percodan. If you are stricken by ache with cancer, backache, or arthritis, then Oxycontin could be a powerful medicine for you. Buy oxycontin online from ShipFromCA pharmacy.

shipfromca said...

Here at the ShipFromCA web site, we tend to pride ourselves on giving all of our website visitors access to a spread of unengaged to use guides, articles and up to date news stories concerning the Buy adderall online.

shipfromca said...

Ambien is used to deal with a sure sleep problem (insomnia) in adults. If you have hassle falling asleep, it facilitates you go to sleep faster, so that you can get a higher night’s rest. Zolpidem belongs to a category of drugs referred to as sedative-hypnotics. It acts in your brain to produce a relaxing effect. For that, you can Buy ambien online.

corpacind said...

sheet of corrugated plastic - Corpac is India’s No.1 Plastic Corrugated Sheets & Box Manufacturer, suppliers in Qatar, New Zealand, Germany, Philippines, UK and Spain.

Ricky Marsh said...

Best Deals at Safemartshop, an international prescription service provider, which contracts with International dispensaries and USA pharmacies, is a leader in referring orders for prescription and non-prescription medications on behalf of customers throughout the world
Safemartshop
buy hydrocodone online
buy oxycodone online
buy oxycontin online
buy percocet online
buy vicodin online
buy norco online
buy adderall online
buy xanax online