Thursday, July 28, 2011

Myraid Alerts Federal Circuit Judges that Key Plaintiff in AMP v. PTO Apparently Cannot Perform Clinical BRCA Testing

During oral arguments in AMP v. PTO (the ACLU/PubPat attack on Myriad Genetic’s BRCA gene patents, previously discussed here), the panel of Federal Circuit judges hearing the case evinced some skepticism as to whether any of the named plaintiffs have standing to bring the lawsuit. For example, many of the plaintiffs are patients who would not appear to be in any real threat of being sued by Myriad for patent infringement.

The plaintiffs most likely to have standing are probably the clinicians who the ACLU argues would engage in BRCA testing were it not for the Myriad patents. However, the declarations by these plaintiffs do not unambiguously state that the plaintiff would begin doing BRCA testing if the patents are invalidated. Instead, they merely declare that the plaintiff has the "capability and desire" to perform the tests, and that the plaintiff "has all the personnel, expertise, and facilities necessary to do various types of sequencing." These declarations were drafted by lawyers, and I think the language used is meaningful, reflecting the fact that these clinicians have not committed to performing BRCA testing if the patents are invalidated.

During oral arguments the Federal Circuit judges pushed the ACLU attorney to clarify whether this language indicated a commitment to perform the tests, implying that a mere "capability and desire" to perform the test might not be sufficient to generate the degree of controversy necessary for standing. In my opinion, the ACLU attorney never provided a clear answer to the question, which suggests that in fact these clinicians have not committed to performing the tests.

Yesterday, Myriad's attorneys sent a letter to the Federal Circuit judges informing them that one of the key clinician plaintiffs who submitted this sort of declaration, Dr. Harry Osterer, has left his position at the NYU Langone Medical Center, and apparently is no longer in a position to offer clinical BRCA genetic testing. Attached to the letter is a printout from the Albert Einstein College of Medicine, identifying Dr. Osterer as a new professor at Albert Einstein. In the letter, Myriad's attorneys state that Albert Einstein does not offer, and is not qualified offer, clinical genetic testing. If this is correct, this seems to further undercut any pretense that he is committed to offering clinical BRCA testing if the patents are invalidated. A copy of the letter is attached here.


hibeyond said...

black boots

Chocolate boots

sand boots

Chestnut boots

gray boots

pink boots

grey boots
pink boots on sale

Black Ugg Boots

Chestnut Ugg


Chocolate Ugg


Grey Ugg Boots

Ugg Boots On Sale

limo rental Fort Lee said...

I trust you made some decent focuses in features.good site that has all the data on the subject of the source code furthermore with respect to the python rental Fort Lee said...

Making share of anthology processing machine software efficiently is surely an essential jam dexterity to see. For this rendezvous an particular happiness breeding capture a sarcastic

online gevonden said...

otal of us extract obtained essentially obtained an superb skill by contemplatives of respect in requisition to distract relating to an atypical internet gevonden

digital signature said...

I haven’t any word to appreciate this post…..Really i am impressed from this post….the person who create this post it was a great human..thanks for shared this with signature

native american pottery said...

source code related to the Searchdaimon enterprise search engine to GitHub, with full commit history. We will be using the GitHub repository internally as our only source code repository from now on. It is currently about 100K lines of code…native american pottery

kids bow ties said...

I laughed out loud, shed some tears … Scrambled Eggs is a theatrical feast for women of all ages and the men who love them!" and CBS’ Magee Hickey “I haven't laughed so hard in years. It's touching, poignant, funny and oh so very real."kids bow ties

Kitchen hood filters said...

What a great source of information. Such a wonderful collection of new ideas. I'll definitely be back!Kitchen hood filters

Drug Prices said...

It will always bе intereѕting to read thrߋugh artiϲles from other ѡriters аnd use a little something from their websіtes.Drug Prices

camtec electrical contractors perth said...

Below you will understand what is important, the idea provides one of the links with an exciting site:camtec electrical contractors perth

80’s costumes said...

David Zimmerman, Tassajara director, expects a rerun. The monks will don yellow, flame-resistant fire jackets and yellow helmets with protective shrouds and will work to stamp out spot fires. Everyone, he said, feels "happy and honored to be here right now.80’s costumes

transfer money abroad said...

If an injury was caused by professional negligence than a malpractice attorney is needed. It may be medical malpractice or legal malpractice that causes the injury. A Maryland medical malpractice attorney will be able to protect victim’s rights in their best interest and do so in a safe and legal manner.transfer money abroad

money transfer companies said...

Admiring the time and effort you put into your blog and detailed information you transfer companies